Why Car Dealers Are Benefiting from Buy-Sell Markets in 2025

The Bright Future of Auto Dealerships Post-Pandemic

As the automotive industry continues to navigate the complexities of 2025, many car dealership owners are finding optimism in a landscape rich with opportunities. According to the recent Kerrigan Advisors Blue Sky report, dealerships have not only managed to withstand challenges but have also emerged stronger, with substantial profits leading the way to a robust buy-sell market.

Industry Dynamics Supporting Growth

The report indicates that average profits among publicly traded auto groups have surged by an astonishing 83% since pre-pandemic levels. This impressive growth can be attributed to the diverse revenue streams within dealerships, which include finance and insurance (F&I) services that have become critical profit centers for many.

Moreover, the expansion in online shopping for vehicles, accelerated during the pandemic, has significantly transformed consumer expectations and dealership operations. As manufacturers adjust pricing strategies in response to fluctuating market conditions, dealerships are presenting a more compelling case to potential buyers.

An Evolving Market Landscape

Despite the estimated $10 billion toll resulting from U.S. trade tariffs, consumer demand remains strong, particularly for electric vehicles as buyers rush to secure tax credits that are on the verge of expiration. This ongoing demand contrasts with rising concerns matching affordability, especially as the average transaction price of new cars recently surpassed the $50,000 mark.

In Kerrigan’s recent survey, a significant 41% of dealers reported that these tariffs had not adversely impacted their sales. With 16% indicating plans for expansion rather than selling, the market shows signs of shift, suggesting a seller's market for those seeking to capitalize on their investments.

Valuations Steadily Increases

An essential development is the marked rise in blue-sky valuations—an indicator of goodwill and potential profitability in dealership sales. The report noted a striking 76% increase in average blue-sky values compared to pre-pandemic benchmarks. This rise is vital for both buyers and sellers as it reflects heightened expectations for financial performance.

Notably, franchises like Toyota and Lexus are commanding premium valuations. Conversely, brands like Nissan lag behind in valuation, signaling potential areas of concern for dealers focused on growth.

Bright Prospects Ahead

Looking toward the future, the Kerrigan report anticipates continued robust buy-sell activity, bolstered by accessible capital for buyers and the persisting focus on profitability improvements. Ongoing advancements in technology, such as artificial intelligence applications, are expected to create operational efficiencies, further enhancing dealership values.

Despite the shifting landscape, one constant remains—the importance of strategic financial management. For dealership principals, leveraging automotive finance services can help capture optimal profits from their operations. Furthermore, the adoption of effective buy-sell strategies will be crucial as the market continues to evolve.

How Dealers Can Capitalize on Current Trends

For car dealers and principals exploring their options, being informed about the trends affecting the automotive finance landscape is paramount. Prioritizing finance options for vehicles and understanding customer needs have never been more vital as affordability challenges persist. This dynamic environment presents an opportunity for innovation in automotive finance that can lead to greater customer satisfaction and retention.

As we move deeper into 2025, staying adaptable and informed on dealership valuations, consumer buying trends, and financial strategies will be crucial for success. Those who embrace these changes will likely be the dealers who thrive, reinforcing the need for ongoing education and market awareness in this rapidly evolving sector.